tibljТуберкулез и болезни легкихTuberculosis and Lung Diseases2075-12302542-1506Медицинские знания и технологии10.21292/2075-1230-2021-99-4-58-64tiblj-1532Research ArticleОБЗОРЫREVIEWSКлинические аспекты применения искусственного интеллекта для интерпретации рентгенограмм органов грудной клеткиClinical aspects of using artificial intelligence for the interpretation of chest X-raysМорозовС. П.MorozovS. P.

Морозов Сергей Павлович – доктор медицинских наук, профессор, директор

127051, Москва, ул. Петровка, д. 24

Sergey P. Morozov – Doctor of Medical Sciences, Professor, Director

24, Petrovka St., Moscow, 127051

morozov@npcmr.ruКокинаД. Ю.KokinaD. Yu.

Кокина Дарья Юрьевна – младший научный сотрудник сектора медицинской информатики, радиомики и радиогеномики

127051, Москва, ул. Петровка, д. 24

Darya Yu. Kokina – Junior Researcher of the Sector of Medical Informatics, Radiomics and Radiogenomics

24, Petrovka St., Moscow, 127051

d.kokina@npcmr.ruПавловН. А.PavlovN. A.

Павлов Николай Александрович – руководитель проекта «Конвейер разметки»

127051, Москва, ул. Петровка, д. 24

Nikolay A. Pavlov – Head of Marking Conveyor Project

24, Petrovka St., Moscow, 127051

n.pavlov@npcmr.ruКирпичевЮ. С.KirpichevYu. S.

Кирпичев Юрий Сергеевич – младший научный сотрудник сектора медицинской информатики, радиомики и радиогеномики

127051, Москва, ул. Петровка, д. 24

Yury S. Kirpichev – Junior Researcher of the Sector of Medical Informatics, Radiomics and Radiogenomics

24, Petrovka St., Moscow, 127051

y.kirpichev@npcmr.ruГомболевскийВ. А.GombolevskiyV. A.

Гомболевский Виктор Александрович – кандидат медицинских наук,руководитель отдела развития качества радиологии

127051, Москва, ул. Петровка, д. 24

Viktor A. Gombolevskiy – Candidate of Medical Sciences, Head of Department for Radiology Quality Enhancement

24, Petrovka St., Moscow, 127051

gombolevskiy@npcmr.ruАндрейченкоА. Е.АndreychenkoA. E.

Андрейченко Анна Евгеньевна – кандидат физико-математических наук, начальник сектора медицинской информатики, радиомики и радиогеномики

127051, Москва, ул. Петровка, д. 24

Anna E. Andreychenko – Candidate of Physical and Mathematical Sciences,Head of the Sector of Medical Informatics, Radiomics and Radiogenomics

24, Petrovka St., Moscow, 127051

a.andreychenko@npcmr.ruГБУЗ города Москвы «Научно-практический клинический центр диагностики и телемедицинских технологий Департамента здравоохранения города Москвы»РоссияScientific Practical Clinical Center of Diagnostics and Telemedicine TechnologiesRussian Federation2021150520219945864Copyright © Морозов С.П., Кокина Д.Ю., Павлов Н.А., Кирпичев Ю.С., Гомболевский В.А., Андрейченко А.Е., 20212021Морозов С.П., Кокина Д.Ю., Павлов Н.А., Кирпичев Ю.С., Гомболевский В.А., Андрейченко А.Е.Morozov S.P., Kokina D.Y., Pavlov N.A., Kirpichev Y.S., Gombolevskiy V.A., Аndreychenko A.E.This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.https://www.tibl-journal.com/jour/article/view/1532

В обзоре рассмотрены возможности применения искусственного интеллекта для интерпретации рентгенограмм органов грудной клетки путем анализа 45 литературных источников. Проанализированы экспериментальные и коммерческие системы диагностики туберкулеза легких, пневмоний, новообразований и других заболеваний.

The review considers the possible use of artificial intelligence for the interpretation of chest X-rays by analyzing 45 publications. Experimental and commercial diagnostic systems for pulmonary tuberculosis, pneumonia, neoplasms and other diseases have been analyzed.

искусственный интеллектрентгенографиятуберкулез легкихзаболевания легкихпульмонологиякомпьютерное зрениеartificial intelligenceradiographypulmonary tuberculosislung diseasespulmonologycomputer visionReferencesМорозов С. П., Владзимирский А. В., Кляшторный В. Г., Андрейченко А. Е., Кульберг Н. С., Гомболевский В. А., Сергунова К. А. Клинические испытания программного обеспечения на основе интеллектуальных технологий (лучевая диагностика). Серия «Лучшие практики лучевой и инструментальной диагностики». – Вып. 57. – М., 2019. – 51 с.Morozov S.P., Vladzimirskiy А.V., Klyashtorny V.G., Аndrejchenko А.E., Kulberg N.S., Gombolevskiy V.А., Sergunova K.А. Klinicheskie ispytaniya programmnogo obespecheniya na osnove intellektualnykh tekhnologiy (luchevaya diagnostika). Seriya Luchshie praktiki luchevoy i instrumentalnoy diagnostiki. [Clinical trials of software based on artificial intelligence technologies (radiology)/ Series of Best practices in medical imaging]. Issue 57, Moscow, 2019, 51 p.Apostolopoulos I. D., Mpesiana T. A. Covid-19: automatic detection from X-ray images utilizing transfer learning with convolutional neural networks // Phys. Eng. Sci. Med. – 2020. – № 43. – P. 635-640.Apostolopoulos I.D., Mpesiana T.A. Covid-19: automatic detection from X-ray images utilizing transfer learning with convolutional neural networks. Phys. Eng. Sci. Med., 2020, no. 43, pp. 635-640.Ather S., Kadir T., Gleeson F. Artificial intelligence and radiomics in pulmonary nodule management: current status and future applications // Clin. Radiol. – 2020. – № 75 (1). – P. 13-19.Ather S., Kadir T., Gleeson F. Artificial intelligence and radiomics in pulmonary nodule management: current status and future applications. Clin. Radiol., 2020, no. 75 (1), pp. 13-19.Behzadi-Khormouji H., Rostami H., Salehi S. et al. Deep learning, reusable and problem-based architectures for detection of consolidation on chest X-ray images // Comput Methods Programs Biomed. – 2020. – № 185. ‒ Р. 105162.Behzadi-Khormouji H., Rostami H., Salehi S. et al. Deep learning, reusable and problem-based architectures for detection of consolidation on chest X-ray images. Comput. Methods Programs Biomed., 2020, no. 185, pp. 105162.Bush I. Lung Nodule Detection and Classification // Report, Stanford Computer Science. – 2016. – 8 p.Bush I. Lung Nodule Detection and Classification. Report, Stanford Computer Science. 2016, 8 p.Cha M. J., Chung M. J., Lee J. H., Lee K. S. Performance of deep learning model in detecting operable lung cancer with chest radiographs // J. Thorac. Imaging. – 2019. – № 34 (2). – P. 86-91.Cha M.J., Chung M.J., Lee J.H., Lee K.S. Performance of deep learning model in detecting operable lung cancer with chest radiographs. J. Thorac. Imaging, 2019, no. 34 (2), pp. 86-91.Chassagnon G., Vakalopoulou M., Paragios N., Revel M. P. Artificial intelligence applications for thoracic imaging // Eur. J. Radiol. – 2020. – № 23. ‒ Р. 108774.Chassagnon G., Vakalopoulou M., Paragios N., Revel M.P. Artificial intelligence applications for thoracic imaging. Eur. J. Radiol., 2020, no. 23, pp. 108774.Chest radiography in tuberculosis detection – summary of current WHO recommendations and guidance on programmatic approaches // World Health Organization. – 2016. – 39 p.Chest radiography in tuberculosis detection – summary of current WHO recommendations and guidance on programmatic approaches. World Health Organization. 2016, 39 p.Del Ciello A., Franchi P., Contegiacomo A., Cicchetti G., Bonomo L., Larici A.R. Missed lung cancer: when, where, and why? // Diagn. Interv. Radiol. – 2017. – № 23 (2). – P. 118-126.Del Ciello A., Franchi P., Contegiacomo A., Cicchetti G., Bonomo L., Larici A.R. Missed lung cancer: when, where, and why? Diagn. Interv. Radiol., 2017, no. 23 (2), pp. 118-126.Global Health Estimates: Deaths by Cause, Age, Sex, by Country and by Region, 2000-2016. Geneva, World Health Organization, 2018.Global Health Estimates: Deaths by Cause, Age, Sex, by Country and by Region, 2000-2016. Geneva, World Health Organization, 2018.Global tuberculosis report 2019 // Geneva: World Health Organization, 2019. – 283 p.Global tuberculosis report 2019. Geneva, World Health Organization, 2019, 283 p.Goutte C., Gaussier E. A Probabilistic interpretation of precision, recall and F-score, with Implication for evaluation // Lecture Notes in Computer Science. – 2005. – 3408. – P. 345-359.Goutte C., Gaussier E.A Probabilistic interpretation of precision, recall and F-score, with Implication for evaluation. Lecture Notes in Computer Science. 2005, 3408, pp. 345-359.Hogeweg L., Mol C., de Jong P. A., Dawson R., Ayles H., van Ginneken B. Fusion of local and global detection systems to detect tuberculosis in chest radiographs // Comput. Assist. Interv. – 2010. – № 13 (3). – P. 650-657.Hogeweg L., Mol C., de Jong P.A., Dawson R., Ayles H., van Ginneken B. Fusion of local and global detection systems to detect tuberculosis in chest radiographs. Comput. Assist. Interv., 2010, no. 13 (3), pp. 650-657.Hwang E. J., Nam J. G., Lim W. H., Park S. J., Jeong Y. S., Kang J. H., Hong E. K., Kim T. M., Goo J. M., Park S., Kim K. H., Park C. M. et al. Deep Learning for Chest Radiograph Diagnosis in the Emergency Department // Radiology. – 2019. – № 293 (3). – P. 573-580.Hwang E.J., Nam J.G., Lim W.H., Park S.J., Jeong Y.S., Kang J.H., Hong E.K., Kim T.M., Goo J.M., Park S., Kim K.H., Park C.M. et al. Deep Learning for Chest Radiograph Diagnosis in the Emergency Department. Radiology, 2019, no. 293 (3), pp. 573-580.Hwang E. J., Park S., Jin K. N. et al. Development and validation of a deep learning-based automated detection algorithm for major thoracic diseases on chest radiographs // JAMA Netw Open. – 2019. – № 2 (3). ‒ Р. 191095.Hwang E.J., Park S., Jin K.N. et al. Development and validation of a deep learning-based automated detection algorithm for major thoracic diseases on chest radiographs. JAMA Netw Open, 2019, no. 2 (3), pp. 191095.Hwang S., Kim H. E., Jeong J., Kim H. J. A novel approach for tuberculosis screening based on deep convolutional neural networks // Proc. SPIE. Medical Imaging. – 2016. – Р. 97852.Hwang S., Kim H.E., Jeong J., Kim H.J. A novel approach for tuberculosis screening based on deep convolutional neural networks. Proc. SPIE. Medical Imaging, 2016, pp. 97852.Jaeger S., Karargyris A., Antani S. et al. Detecting tuberculosis in radiographs using combined lung masks // In: 2012 Annual International Conference of the IEEE Engineering in Medicine and Biology Society, IEEE. – 2012. – P. 4978-4981.Jaeger S., Karargyris A., Antani S. et al. Detecting tuberculosis in radiographs using combined lung masks. In: 2012 Annual International Conference of the IEEE Engineering in Medicine and Biology Society, IEEE. 2012, pp. 4978-4981.Jaeger S., Karargyris A., Candemir S. et al. Automatic screening for tuberculosis in chest radiographs: a survey // Quant Imaging Med Surg. – 2013. – № 3 (2). – P. 89-99.Jaeger S., Karargyris A., Candemir S. et al. Automatic screening for tuberculosis in chest radiographs: a survey. Quant. Imaging Med. Surg., 2013, no. 3 (2), pp. 89-99.Jaeger S., Karargyris A., Candemir S., Folio L., Siegelman J., Callaghan F. M., Xue Z., Palaniappan K., Singh R. K., Antani S., Thoma G. R., Wang Y., Lu P., McDonald C. J. Automatic tuberculosis screening using chest radiographs // IEEE Trans. Med.Imaging. – 2014. – № 33 (2). – P. 233-245.Jaeger S., Karargyris A., Candemir S., Folio L., Siegelman J., Callaghan F. M., Xue Z., Palaniappan K., Singh R.K., Antani S., Thoma G. R., Wang Y., Lu P., McDonald C. J. Automatic tuberculosis screening using chest radiographs. IEEE Trans. Med. Imaging, 2014, no. 33 (2), pp. 233-245.Kallianos K., Mongan J., Antani S. et al. How far have we come? Artificial intelligence for chest radiograph interpretation // Clin. Radiol. – 2019. – № 74 (5). – P. 338-345.Kallianos K., Mongan J., Antani S. et al. How far have we come? Artificial intelligence for chest radiograph interpretation. Clin. Radiol., 2019, no. 74 (5), pp. 338-345.Khan A. I., Shah J. L., Bhat M. M. CoroNet: A deep neural network for detection and diagnosis of COVID-19 from chest x-ray images // Computer Methods and Programs in Biomedicine. – 2020. – 196.Khan A.I., Shah J.L., Bhat M.M. CoroNet: A deep neural network for detection and diagnosis of COVID-19 from chest x-ray images. Computer Methods and Programs in Biomedicine. 2020, 196.Kulkarni S., Jha S. Artificial intelligence, radiology, and tuberculosis: a review // Acad Radiol. – 2020. – № 27 (1). – P. 71-75.Kulkarni S., Jha S. Artificial intelligence, radiology, and tuberculosis: a review. Acad. Radiol., 2020, no. 27 (1), pp. 71-75.Lakhani P., Sundaram B. Deep learning at chest radiography: automated classification of pulmonary tuberculosis by using convolutional neural networks // Radiology. – 2017. – № 284 (2). – P.574-582.Lakhani P., Sundaram B. Deep learning at chest radiography: automated classification of pulmonary tuberculosis by using convolutional neural networks. Radiology, 2017, no. 284 (2), pp. 574-582.Mahomed N., van Ginneken B., Philipsen R. H. H. M. et al. Computer-aided diagnosis for World Health Organization-defined chest radiograph primary-endpoint pneumonia in children // Pediatr Radiol. – 2020. – № 50 (4). – P. 482‐491.Mahomed N., van Ginneken B., Philipsen R.H.H.M. et al. Computer-aided diagnosis for World Health Organization-defined chest radiograph primary-endpoint pneumonia in children. Pediatr. Radiol., 2020, no. 50 (4), pp. 482-491.Matsubara N., Teramoto A., Saito K. et al. Bone suppression for chest X-ray image using a convolutional neural filter // Phys Eng Sci Med. – 2020. – № 43. – P. 97-108.Matsubara N., Teramoto A., Saito K. et al. Bone suppression for chest X-ray image using a convolutional neural filter. Phys. Eng. Sci. Med., 2020, no. 43, pp. 97-108.Melendez J., Sanchez C.I., Philipsen R. H. H. M. et al. An automated tuberculosis screening strategy combining X-ray-based computer-aided detection and clinical information // Sci. Rep. – 2016. – № 6. ‒ Р. 25265.Melendez J., Sanchez C.I., Philipsen R.H.H.M. et al. An automated tuberculosis screening strategy combining X-ray-based computer-aided detection and clinical information. Sci. Rep., 2016, no. 6, pp. 25265.Murphy K., Habib S. S., Zaidi S. M. A. et al. Computer aided detection of tuberculosis on chest radiographs: an evaluation of the CAD4TB v6 system // Sci. Rep. – 2020. – № 10. ‒ Р. 5492.Murphy K., Habib S.S., Zaidi S.M.A. et al. Computer aided detection of tuberculosis on chest radiographs: an evaluation of the CAD4TB v6 system. Sci. Rep., 2020, no. 10, pp. 5492.Nam J. G., Park S., Hwang E. J., Lee J. H., Jin K.-N., Lim K. Y., Vu T. H., Sohn J. H., Hwang S., Goo J. M., Park C. M. Development and validation of deep learning-based automatic detection algorithm for malignant pulmonary nodules on chest radiographs // Radiology. – 2019. – 290. – P. 218-228.Nam J.G., Park S., Hwang E.J., Lee J.H., Jin K.N., Lim K.Y., Vu T.H., Sohn J.H., Hwang S., Goo J.M., Park C.M. Development and validation of deep learning-based automatic detection algorithm for malignant pulmonary nodules on chest radiographs. Radiology, 2019, 290, pp. 218-228.Narin A., Kaya C., Pamuk Z. Automatic Detection of Coronavirus Disease (COVID-19) Using X-Ray Images and Deep Convolutional Neural Networks // arXiv preprint arXiv:2003.10849. 2020.Narin A., Kaya C., Pamuk Z. Automatic Detection of Coronavirus Disease (COVID-19) Using X-Ray Images and Deep Convolutional Neural Networks. arXiv preprint arXiv:2003.10849. 2020.National Lung Screening Trial Research Team, Aberle D. R., Adams A. M., et al. Reduced lung-cancer mortality with low-dose computed tomographic screening // N. Engl. J. Med. – 2011. – № 365 (5). ‒ Р. 395-409.National Lung Screening Trial Research Team, Aberle D. R., Adams A. M., et al. Reduced lung-cancer mortality with low-dose computed tomographic screening. N. Engl. J. Med., 2011, no. 365 (5), pp. 395-409.Pande T., Cohen C., Pai M., Ahmad Khan F. Computer-aided detection of pulmonary tuberculosis on digital chest radiographs: a systematic review // Int. J. Tuberc. Lung Dis. – 2016. – № 20 (9). – P. 1226-1230.Pande T., Cohen C., Pai M., Ahmad Khan F. Computer-aided detection of pulmonary tuberculosis on digital chest radiographs: a systematic review. Int. J. Tuberc. Lung Dis., 2016, no. 20 (9), pp. 1226-1230.Pasa F., Golkov V., Pfeiffer F. et al. Efficient deep network architectures for fast chest x-ray tuberculosis screening and visualization // Sci. Rep. – 2019. – № 9. – P. 62-68.Pasa F., Golkov V., Pfeiffer F. et al. Efficient deep network architectures for fast chest x-ray tuberculosis screening and visualization. Sci. Rep., 2019, no. 9, pp. 62-68.Putha P., Tadepalli M., Reddy B., Raj T., Chiramal J. A., Govil S., Sinha N., Reddivari S., Jagirdar A., Rao P., Warier P. Can Artificial intelligence reliably report chest X-Rays?: radiologist validation of an algorithm trained on 1.2 million X-Rays // arXiv preprint arXiv:1807.07455 (2018).Putha P., Tadepalli M., Reddy B., Raj T., Chiramal J.A., Govil S., Sinha N., Reddivari S., Jagirdar A., Rao P., Warier P. Can Artificial intelligence reliably report chest X-Rays?: radiologist validation of an algorithm trained on 1.2 million X-Rays. arXiv preprint arXiv:1807.07455 (2018).Qin C., Yao D., Shi Y., Song Z. Computer-aided detection in chest radiography based on artificial intelligence: a survey // Biomed. Eng. Online. – 2018. – № 17 (1). ‒ Р. 113.Qin C., Yao D., Shi Y., Song Z. Computer-aided detection in chest radiography based on artificial intelligence: a survey. Biomed. Eng. Online, 2018, no. 17 (1), pp. 113.Qin Z. Z., Sander M. S., Rai B. et al. Using artificial intelligence to read chest radiographs for tuberculosis detection: A multi-site evaluation of the diagnostic accuracy of three deep learning systems // Sci Rep 9. – 2019. – 15000.Qin Z.Z., Sander M.S., Rai B. et al. Using artificial intelligence to read chest radiographs for tuberculosis detection: A multi-site evaluation of the diagnostic accuracy of three deep learning systems. Sci. Rep. 9, 2019, 15000.Rahimzadeh M., Attar A. A modified deep convolutional neural network for detecting COVID-19 and pneumonia from chest X-ray images based on the concatenation of Xception and ResNet50V2 // Inform. Med. Unlocked. – 2020. – № 19. ‒ Р. 100360.Rahimzadeh M., Attar A.A modified deep convolutional neural network for detecting COVID-19 and pneumonia from chest X-ray images based on the concatenation of Xception and ResNet50V2. Inform. Med. Unlocked., 2020, no. 19, pp. 100360.Rahman M. T., Codlin A. J., Rahman M. M. et al. An evaluation of automated chest radiography reading software for tuberculosis screening among public- and private-sector patients // Eur. Respir. J. – 2017. – № 49 (5). ‒ Р. 1602159.Rahman M.T., Codlin A.J., Rahman M.M. et al. An evaluation of automated chest radiography reading software for tuberculosis screening among public- and private-sector patients. Eur. Respir. J., 2017, no. 49 (5), pp. 1602159.Rajpurkar P., Irvin J., Zhu K., Yang B., Mehta H., Duan T., Ding D., Bagul A., Langlotz C., Shpanskaya K. Chexnet: Radiologist-level pneumonia detection on chest x-rays with deep learning // ArXiv Prepr ArXiv:171105225 (2017).Rajpurkar P., Irvin J., Zhu K., Yang B., Mehta H., Duan T., Ding D., Bagul A., Langlotz C., Shpanskaya K. Chexnet: Radiologist-level pneumonia detection on chest x-rays with deep learning. ArXiv Prepr ArXiv:171105225 (2017).Raoof S., Feigin D., Sung A., Raoof S., Irugulpati L., Rosenow E. C. 3rd. Interpretation of plain chest roentgenogram // Chest. – 2012. – № 141 (2). – P. 545-558.Raoof S., Feigin D., Sung A., Raoof S., Irugulpati L., Rosenow E.C. 3rd. Interpretation of plain chest roentgenogram. Chest, 2012, no. 141 (2), pp. 545-558.Sim Y., Chung M. J., Kotter E. et al. Deep convolutional neural network-based software improves radiologist detection of malignant lung nodules on chest radiographs // Radiology. – 2020. – № 294 (1). – P. 199-209.Sim Y., Chung M.J., Kotter E. et al. Deep convolutional neural network-based software improves radiologist detection of malignant lung nodules on chest radiographs. Radiology, 2020, no. 294 (1), pp. 199-209.Taylor A. G., Mielke C., Mongan J. Automated detection of moderate and large pneumothorax on frontal chest X-rays using deep convolutional neural networks: A retrospective study // PLoS Med. – 2018. – № 15 (11). – Р. 1002697.Taylor A. G., Mielke C., Mongan J. Automated detection of moderate and large pneumothorax on frontal chest X-rays using deep convolutional neural networks: A retrospective study. PLos Med., 2018, no. 15 (11), pp. 1002697.White C. S., Flukinger T., Jeudy J., Chen J. J. Use of a computer-aided detection system to detect missed lung cancer at chest radiography // Radiology. – 2009. – № 252 (1). – P. 273-281.White C.S., Flukinger T., Jeudy J., Chen J.J. Use of a computer-aided detection system to detect missed lung cancer at chest radiography. Radiology, 2009, no. 252 (1), pp. 273-281.Xu T., Cheng I., Long R. et al. Novel coarse-to-fine dual scale technique for tuberculosis cavity detection in chest radiographs // J. Image Video Proc. – 2013. – 3.Xu T., Cheng I., Long R. et al. Novel coarse-to-fine dual scale technique for tuberculosis cavity detection in chest radiographs. J. Image Video Proc., 2013, 3.Zaidi S. M. A., Habib S. S., Van Ginneken B. et al. Evaluation of the diagnostic accuracy of Computer-Aided Detection of tuberculosis on Chest radiography among private sector patients in Pakistan // Sci. Rep. – 2018. – № 8 (1). ‒ Р. 12339.Zaidi S.M.A., Habib S.S., Van Ginneken B. et al. Evaluation of the diagnostic accuracy of Computer-Aided Detection of tuberculosis on Chest radiography among private sector patients in Pakistan. Sci. Rep., 2018, no. 8 (1), pp. 12339.Zhou S., Zhang X., Zhang R. Identifying Cardiomegaly in ChestX-ray8 Using Transfer Learning // Stud Health Technol Inform. – 2019. – № 264. – P. 482‐486.Zhou S., Zhang X., Zhang R. Identifying Cardiomegaly in ChestX-ray8 Using Transfer Learning. Stud. Health Technol. Inform., 2019, no. 264, pp. 482‐486.

The authors declare that there are no conflicts of interest present.